social/scientific debate arose in psychiatry, as in the case of medico-legal disputes over individual responsibility in property laws, the Enlightenment project of civilising the les enfants sauvage as a means of exploring human potentials, and the racial politics of Social Darwinism that gave rise to the notorious term ‘Mongolism’. By unveiling the complex and sometimes tragic family history of John Langdon Down
نویسنده
چکیده
In the age of prenatal screening and early intervention even at the molecular level, much has been said about the politics of geneticisation, yet relatively little remains known about how this politics actually shapes people's experiences. In this exquisite book about the history of Downs syndrome, which won the 2013 Dingle Prize by the British Society for the History of Science, Wright shows us how people influenced by genetic self-knowledge and their families have come to creatively reshape their identities, and in the process, transform popular and scientific assumptions about the boundaries of human nature. Wright's account makes it clear that one can re-read the history of psychiatry with a refreshingly new perspective through the lens of Downs. Downs seem to have always been there whenever a new crucial social/scientific debate arose in psychiatry, as in the case of medico-legal disputes over individual responsibility in property laws, the Enlightenment project of civilising the les enfants sauvage as a means of exploring human potentials, and the racial politics of Social Darwinism that gave rise to the notorious term 'Mongolism'. By unveiling the complex and sometimes tragic family history of John Langdon Down and his descendants and the Catholic crusade of Jérôme Lejeune (whose status as the discoverer of trisomy 21 is now in dispute), Wright fully explores the moral ambiguities of science, with which heroic attempts to help the disabled have at times unwittingly inflicted suffering on those who were meant to be saved. Indeed, the most striking aspect of the history of Downs is the bitter fruit of genetic science: the discovery of trisomy 21 has made the public more sympathetic and accepting of those born with this disability, yet this very technology has made it almost possible to eradicate them through prenatal screening. Wright's account also demonstrates that, despite the seeming universality of Downs, the images and actual experiences of it have been diverse, shaped as much by local politics of difference as by scientific knowledge. While the initial genetic discovery helped de-stigmatise Downs, it also gave rise to debates in bioethics about whether to withdraw life-saving measures for babies born with this disability. Documenting the era of institutionalisation and subsequent patient activism, Wright shows how people with Downs have been at the forefront of questioning cerebral subjectivity. Today, people with Downs are more visible than ever in the community; they go to college, get married, get a job, …
منابع مشابه
I-27: Determining the Status of Non-TransferredEmbryos in Ireland: A Conspectus of
The development of in vitro fertilisation (IVF) as a treatment for human infertilty was among the most controversial medical achievements of the modern era. In Ireland, the fate and status of supranumary (non-transferred) embryos derived from IVF brings challenges both for clinical practice and public health policy because there is no judicial or legislative framework in place to address the me...
متن کاملI-43: Scientific and Religious Controversies on The Beginning of Human Life- What Does 3D/4D Sonography Offer?
One of the most controversial topics in modern bioethics, science, and philosophy is the beginning of individual human life. In the seemingly endless debate, strongly stimulated by recent technologic advances in human reproduction, a synthesis between scientific data and hypothesis, philosophical thought, and issues of humanities has become a necessity to deal with ethical, juridical, and socia...
متن کاملAnalytical, Legal and Ethical Look at Harassment Litigation
Background: The coexistence of human beings requires the observance of moral etiquette, which is called civil ethics in ethics and leads to normative order. In order for civil ethics to have an executive guarantee, a set of laws was formed in the society under the title of civil procedure. One of the lawsuits in this regard is the harassment lawsuit. There are complex issues in the harassment l...
متن کاملExperiences and challenges of girls with a history of cohabitation
Background The process of modernization and globalization and changes in the value system have gradually given rise to new and unusual patterns of relationships among some Iranian youth. One of the most extreme forms of premarital relationships is the emergence of cohabitation patterns. A model of a relationship that has deep Western roots, stemming from social and economic developments, espe...
متن کاملExperiences and challenges of girls with a history of cohabitation
Background The process of modernization and globalization and changes in the value system have gradually given rise to new and unusual patterns of relationships among some Iranian youth. One of the most extreme forms of premarital relationships is the emergence of cohabitation patterns. A model of a relationship that has deep Western roots, stemming from social and economic developments, espe...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره 58 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2014